Loading...
Publication
Effectiveness of grade retention: A systematic review and meta-analysis
| Name: | Description: | Size: | Format: | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.44 MB | Adobe PDF |
Advisor(s)
Abstract(s)
Research on the effectiveness of grade retention has a long history, yet, has seen an upsurge
during the last decade. In this study, we review 84 recent, methodologically sound studies estimating
effects of retention in grades K-12 on repeaters’ and nonrepeaters’ development, in a
variety of countries across the world, disentangling grade and age comparison results. Based on
vote counting analysis and three-level metaregression analysis we find grade retention to have an
average zero effect, indicating that repeaters and non-repeaters seem to show a similar development,
on average. At the same time, we find grade retention effects to differ according to some
specific effect and study characteristics. More specifically, grade retention seems less effective in
countries applying a mixture of grade retention and tracking to tackle student heterogeneity, and
when repeaters are compared with non-repeaters of the same age. Conversely, grade retention
seems more effective in countries using strategies such as ability grouping, setting, and streaming
to deal with student heterogeneity. Positive effects also seem to arise when studying students’
psychosocial functioning, when investigating short-run effects, when comparing repeaters with
their younger non-retained grade-mates, and when evaluating effects via a regression discontinuity
method.
Description
Keywords
Effectiveness Meta-analysis Learning outcomes Grade retention K-12 education
Citation
Goos, M., Pipa, J., & Peixoto, F. (2021). Effectiveness of grade retention: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Educational Research Review, 34. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2021.100401
Publisher
Elsevier Ltd.