Utilize este identificador para referenciar este registo: http://hdl.handle.net/10400.12/1193
Título: Reasoning with deontic and counterfactual conditionals
Autor: Quelhas, Ana Cristina
Byrne, Ruth M. J.
Data: 2003
Editora: Psychology Press
Citação: Thinking and Reasoning, 9(1), 43-65
Resumo: We report two new phenomena of deontic reasoning: (1) For conditionals with deontic content such as, “If the nurse cleaned up the blood then she must have worn rubber gloves”, reasoners make more modus tollens inferences (from “she did not wear rubber gloves” to “she did not clean up the blood”) compared to conditionals with epistemic content. (2) For conditionals in the subjunctive mood with deontic content, such as, “If the nurse had cleaned up the blood then she must have had to wear rubber gloves”, reasoners make the same frequency of all inferences as they do for conditionals in the indicative mood with deontic content. In this regard, subjunctive deontics are different from subjunctive epistemic conditionals: reasoners interpret subjunctive epistemic conditionals as counterfactual and they make more negative inferences such as modus tollens from them. The experiments show these two phenomena occur for deontic conditionals that contain the modal auxiliary “must” and ones that do not. We discuss the results in terms of the mental representations of deontic conditionals and of counterfactual conditionals.
Peer review: yes
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10400.12/1193
ISSN: 1354-6783
Aparece nas colecções:UIPCDE - Artigos em revistas internacionais
PCOG - Artigos em revistas internacionais

Ficheiros deste registo:
Ficheiro Descrição TamanhoFormato 
TR 9(1) 43.pdf129,28 kBAdobe PDFVer/Abrir

FacebookTwitterDeliciousLinkedInDiggGoogle BookmarksMySpace
Formato BibTex MendeleyEndnote 

Todos os registos no repositório estão protegidos por leis de copyright, com todos os direitos reservados.